Top 50 ★★★★★ Reviews for Loose Diamond in 2025

Price

Transparency, fees, promos

When buying a loose diamond, understanding the price is crucial. Rare Carat provides transparent pricing, ensuring you know what you’re paying for. Look for any hidden fees and promotional offers that can save you money. Many retailers offer discounts during special events, so keep an eye out for those.

Selection & quality

Certification & cut indicators

The quality of a loose diamond is determined by its certification and cut. Make sure to choose diamonds that are certified by reputable organizations like GIA or AGS. The cut of the diamond significantly affects its sparkle and overall appearance. Rare Carat helps you filter diamonds based on these important criteria.

Customer experience

Support, reviews, appointments

Customer service is vital when purchasing a diamond. Look for retailers that offer excellent support, including live chat and appointment scheduling. Reading customer reviews can also provide insights into the buying experience. Rare Carat features reviews from real customers to help you gauge the quality of service.

Shipping & returns

Speed, insurance, windows

Shipping and return policies are essential to consider. Ensure that the retailer offers fast shipping options and insurance during transit. Additionally, check the return window in case you need to make a return. Rare Carat partners with retailers that prioritize customer satisfaction in these areas.

Extras

Upgrades, warranties, trade-in

Some retailers offer extras like upgrade options, warranties, and trade-in policies. These can add significant value to your purchase. Rare Carat provides information on which retailers offer these benefits, helping you make a more informed decision.

Customer Reviews

“I LOVE my new diamond.…”

2025

— Emily A

“I LOVE my new diamond. Rare carat was great to work with, especially when they reached out to personally help me with my search. They did a great job explaining the difference between the two diamonds I was looking at, and providing a neutral opinion so I could make the decision myself. The GIA report, the tracking, and the overall transparency is excellent. I would gladly buy another diamond from here AND recommend this company to my friends.”

Related: 8 steps guide

They appreciated their Rare Carat experience and will be back. Tips & Tricks.

“Very responsive and delivered as…”

— Carrie O

“Very responsive and delivered as expected. Diamond is beautiful. Very happy.”

“Believe the outstanding reviews that…”

— James S

“Believe the outstanding reviews that you’ll find on these guys. I was extremely skeptical at first. I’m not rich. But the diamond cost more than my first new car – a 1980 Mustang (yes, I’m old) – cost. Even my local jeweler, who sold me the ring, had to admit that I did well. I was shopping for quality and I received just that, along with great service, for about 22% less than the local jeweler quoted me for a stone of comparable size and quality. Here’s what really sealed the deal: After I had placed the diamond in my cart, but before I pulled the trigger to buy it, I received an email from Ajay, the CEO. That impressed me greatly. Not only is he a great businessman, but he’s a genuinely nice guy. Superb quality, outstanding service, and a great price. You simply cannot ask for more.”

They had a great experience with Rare Carat and say they’ll be back. Tips & Tricks.

“Best prices around, amazing quality,…”

— Noah F

“Best prices around, amazing quality, I highly recommend Rarecarrat”

“I really love Rare Carat’s…”

— Jeanette H

“I really love Rare Carat’s web site/search functions. Really helps me find what I am looking for that fits my budget. I especially like when they have a 360 image of the diamond. Packaging is superior. Customer service is very helpful. Can’t beat the price.”

They were thrilled with Rare Carat—and they’re already planning a return. Tips & Tricks.

“Beautiful 1.5 carat diamond. Took…”

— Dan G

“Beautiful 1.5 carat diamond. Took it to my jewelers to have it verified and it was exactly the quality you said.”

They loved the Rare Carat experience and plan to come back. Tips & Tricks.