Engagement Ring Reviews You Can Trust

Discover the ideal ring with verified reviews, expert comparisons, and a variety of styles, including solitaires and vintage designs.

Latest Guides & Insights

Not just reviews - we educate you in buying smarter. We have diamond buying guides and engagement ring education cover:

Featured Article

Top 50 ★★★★★ Reviews for Engagement Ring in 2025

Top 50 ★★★★★ Reviews for Wedding Band in 2025

Top 50 ★★★★★ Reviews for Bracelet in 2025

Top 50 ★★★★★ Reviews for Necklace in 2025

Top 50 ★★★★★ Reviews for Loose Diamond in 2025

Top 100 Most-Loved White Gold Engagement Ring Reviews in 2025

News

Editor's picks

Our editors bring you the most authentic engagement ring reviews submitted by customers. See real photos, ratings and real experiences - honestly, with no deception.

New Reviews

“"Happy wife, happy life!"”


5 out of 5
— Erin A






"My husband and I discovered rare carat after researching with several local jewelers and online vendors. I was immediately impressed with the gemologists. They took the list of things we were looking for in a diamond, told us what was realistic within our price range and ran with it. They sent us several diamonds over the course of a few weeks and I knew the one I wanted as soon as I saw it. Some of the diamonds on their site were listed with other online retailers but when I asked them about the specifics they gave their honest, unbiased and detailed opinions. I had not experienced this with any other seller. My husband and I were also in the market for a custom setting but were concerned about the quality and purchasing something that would be non-refundable so we decided to go with a setting that was available online and would still be able to be returned within 30 days. We thought we would check out the workmanship and if we were happy would then consider designing something. Well the ring that came was stunning and I would have no issue ordering custom from them in the future (the team was excellent and incredibly patient while answering all of my questions) but I couldn’t send back the one that was delivered because I was so happy with it. We went in searching for a round or oval solitaire close to 2 carats and ended up with a 1.63 carat (9.65 x 6.50) oval cut diamond (color H, VVS1) in the 14 karat yellow gold Aria setting. The price was more competitive than the other online vendors. The same diamond was close to $1,200 more on another site. We highly recommend working with Rare Carat. We are so happy with our experience! PS The headline was the advice from my father on our wedding day. Although I waited over a decade for this beautiful ring, it was worth it and my Dad wasn’t wrong!"

Go Rare Carat

Why Trust EngagementRingReviews.com?

Independent Reviews. Real Buyer Stories. Expert Guidance.

We make jewelry shopping simple, clear and inspiring. We combine real buyer experiences, with expert testing of diamonds and engagement rings. This helps you compare, sparkle, quality, comfort and customer service.

Stay Update

Subscribe to get the latest engagement ring reviews, diamond insights, and jewelry buying tips delivered straight to your inbox.

"Exceptional Brilliance and Cut Quality"

-

Jennifer K.

,2025

"The vintage-inspired design is exactly what I wanted. The attention to detail in the setting complements the diamond perfectly. A true work of art."

"Exceptional Brilliance and Cut Quality"

"The diamond exceeded all my expectations. The sparkle is incredible and the cut is absolutely perfect. Every angle catches the light beautifully."

-

Sarah M.

,2025

"Outstanding Customer Service Experience"

"Not only is the diamond stunning, but the entire purchasing experience was flawless. Expert guidance throughout the selection process."

-

Michael R.

,2025

"Perfect for My Engagement Ring"

"Found exactly what I was looking for. The clarity and color are remarkable. My fiancée absolutely loves it!"

-

David L.

,2025

The Ultimate Guide to Diamond Cut Quality

"Perfect sparkle and amazing craftsmanship!"

-

A.R.

,2025

Learn how cut quality affects a diamond's brilliance and fire. Expert insights on choosing the perfect cut for maximum sparkle and value.

The Ultimate Guide to Diamond Cut Quality

"Perfect sparkle and amazing craftsmanship!"

-

Sarah M.

,2025

Learn how cut quality affects a diamond's brilliance and fire. Expert insights on choosing the perfect cut for maximum sparkle.

2025 Diamond Trends: What's Popular Now

"Exactly what I was looking for!"

-

M.K.

,2025

Discover the latest trends in diamond shapes, settings, and styles that are captivating buyers this year.

Comparing Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamonds

"Stunning Vintage-Style Setting"

-

Miche

,2025

An honest comparison of lab-grown and natural diamonds, covering quality, value, and environmental impact.

Making rings & diamond discovery effortless, trustworthy, and inspiring through authentic reviews and expert guidance.

Stay Update

Get the latest diamond reviews, expert guides, and industry insights delivered to your inbox.

© 2026 All Rights Reserved.